Hello,
"Basics: 1994 Golf 3 TDI 1Z, owned since '99, current mileage approximately 120,000 km (assuming the original mileage figures are correct), likely a test engine from Emden, possibly Audi-sourced. Engine control unit with hand-painted chips, stripped wiring harness (Winkler minimal system...)"
I'm having (again) problems with my stator. The starting behavior was poor, and the ESP values were off, so I took the whole thing apart.
"Where the arrows are, you can see the color marking from the last timing belt replacement. The marking on the timing belt sprocket is rotated a few degrees counter-clockwise relative to the crankshaft bolt. That's why my theory is that the bolt itself is tight, but the sprocket has rotated. The adjusted timing/ESP data seems to support this."
"This isn't the first time this has happened. I've already had a stripped screw and a loose screw. When the first screw stripped, it was already a 12.x screw installed (the 94, 1Z TDI was originally supposed to have a 'softer' 10.x screw)."
This means that at least the third gear is damaged (and likely the crankshaft stub has corresponding damage).
VW repaired the damage from the previous dismantling (it lasted 20,000 km), and I addressed the loose screw last winter (I used a stub cutter from KW, and it's been 10,000 km since then). At that time, after talking to a VW master technician, I installed the gear with a very thin layer of Loctite and the screw without any Loctite on the threads, but with a little Loctite on the flange.
If the toothed wheel rotates without the screw becoming loose, then the flat surface on the shock absorber likely has a defect.
Since the flattening is slightly angled, if you were to re-mill it, you would need to go deeper (into the healthy area?).
Has anyone ever repeatedly ground down the same crankshaft? How much material can be removed without causing problems? And does that really help? Or would ultimately only a different crankshaft solve the issue?
That would require removing the engine, and the effort involved (finding a workshop, removing the engine, partially disassembling it, etc.) is honestly a bit too much for me, given the problem. (I'd rather just install something else directly.)
What do you think? Is there still a chance for a repair?
Hi, Marcus.