VCDS and OBD diagnostic device in the On-Board Diagnostics Shop
Wrenchers and tuners: diesel, petrol, OBD/VCDS. Repair, maintenance, diagnostics - help that's proven on the car.

Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences

 
Go to page: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
New Topic Reply 🔗 ⭐ 🖨 Dieselschrauber - Index » Diesel Engine Technology
Author Message
Thomas
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/17/2002
Posts: 329
Karma: +2 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Darmstadt

Support

jodybas likes this.
Post23-05-2003, 9:49    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Hello, fellow diesel enthusiasts!

First, regarding the legal aspects. I am writing here about my personal experiences, which are not universally applicable. Everyone is free to draw their own conclusions from this.

On March 13, 2003, I had an appointment with one of the most well-known tuning shops in Germany.
I had arranged this appointment by phone about two weeks prior. Until now, almost everything I've read about this tuner has been positive. That's why I was tempted to try it, but...
to be proven wrong.

My vehicle is a 1997 VW Golf 3 with 140,000 km on the odometer, and the engine code is AFN.

The phone call

My request was to have the software adjusted for the larger nozzles of my T4 Caravelle with a 110kW engine. After internal consultation, I was assured that this would not be a problem, but my vehicle might need to be put on a test bench to test individual functions and versions of the tuning software.

Since I was only interested in having the test performed on a dynamometer, we quickly came to an agreement. I was quoted a price of approximately 950 euros.
It also included a "beta mode." (Brief explanation: The chips have twice as much memory as the standard ones. The standard software is loaded into the lower address range, and the modified software is loaded into the upper range. In the middle, a control wire is soldered, which conducts electricity once and not at other times. A simple switch from Conrad would therefore more than meet the requirements!)
The mechanic mentioned that I could waive the warranty and the parts inspection report, which would reduce the price by approximately 270 euros. I agreed to this and confirmed the appointment.

March 13, 2003, 9:00 AM

Before I begin: A friend accompanied me, and he can confirm the following text.

We arrived on time. At the reception, they were unaware of my larger injectors, and the gentleman I had spoken to on the phone was not present. I was sent to the workshop, where they also knew nothing about the injectors. The employees of the tuning shop insisted that these injectors would not provide any benefit and that they would "chip" my car to 140 horsepower. Only after a lengthy discussion were they willing to accommodate my requests.

Specialized expertise?

"During the removal of the control unit, the technician caused the leaves that were around the cabin air filter to fall into the blower motor. I had to disassemble and clean everything at home after I had leaves constantly flying at me during the drive back."

"The technician disconnected the pressure hose from the pressure sensor in the control unit and said the turbocharger was completely fine. He explained to me that this is because no oil is dripping from the hose. (My crankcase ventilation system has been open for some time and is not connected to the intake manifold.)"

3.) The entire team ridiculed me for installing larger injectors, claiming they would increase power. They rolled their eyes or laughed. On the dyno, the engine, with its stock software and larger injectors, produced 20 horsepower and 35 Nm more. The tuner's explanation was, "Your engine is just really well-tuned!"

4.) I was told that the mixture is made very rich "at the top" to cool the valves. The pistons are not at risk.

5.) I should disconnect the EGR valve, as it causes soot buildup.

6.) When driving onto the inspection platform, no consideration was given. After the standard suspension wore out, my car was fitted with a yellow Koni suspension. This suspension lowers the body by 30mm, which isn't a huge amount. The technician drove onto the platform with considerable speed. I could clearly see and hear which parts were hitting and scraping. While it might have happened even at a slightly lower speed, it reflected a certain lack of care.

When I asked if it wouldn't be better to remove the front spoiler lip, the technician responded with the question: "Should I take it off?" The car was lying on the ground with the front spoiler touching the surface. The two parts can be removed with just two movements. It doesn't take even a minute.

Customer policy

Over the phone, I was promised a dyno tuning session. For 950 euros, that didn't seem like too much to ask. However, once I arrived and the base plates were installed, I was told that they don't do that kind of thing, as they supposedly know the engine inside and out and it's not necessary. They claimed that the maximum performance had already been achieved. A dyno tuning session would cost 200 euros per hour.

At that point, I was very frustrated and wanted to speak with someone from their management. I was told that the arrangement made over the phone was just a formality, as the person I spoke with was just a trainee who didn't know much. That's what I was told. When the person arrived, there was a brief reprimand, and then the matter was supposedly settled. To appease me, they offered to run my car on the dynamometer a few times for €77 and to make some minor adjustments to the software for my engine. I agreed for two reasons: first, to achieve my goal, and second, because I was concerned that this tuner might later make further changes to the software that could cause premature engine failure. There was a risk, as I had already waived the warranty, and the employees didn't seem trustworthy.

Finally, there was one last point of contention, which I thought I had already resolved over the phone. I wanted the tuning to be switchable. Incidentally, this was only possible at a very high extra cost. Now I had to justify why I wanted such a feature. I didn't feel like I was being advised; I felt pressured.

The customer is king, or is he not?

Overall, I wasn't treated like a customer, but rather like a burden that just happened to bring in money. I mostly refrained from asking questions or making requests, but the reactions of the staff still gave the impression that they would have preferred I just park the car, go for a walk for a few hours, and then come back to pay.

We would regularly take cigarette breaks, standing outside the door and talking. They refused to install a switch, arguing that they couldn't do it properly to my satisfaction. They would drill a hole somewhere and screw the switch in. They told me I should just do it myself at home. Every question seemed to be too much for them, although I have to make an exception for the programmer. Towards the end, I was actually able to have a decent conversation with him.

The technician told me that this job "really annoys" him and that he only does it for the money. He used to work on his own car, but he's not interested in that kind of thing anymore.

The highlight

Normally, considering the points mentioned earlier, it would almost be too much for me to even write such a text. But I believe the following requires it of me.

The two people I overheard were talking about an Opel Omega that they had modified the day before. One of them said that after a customer complaint, the company had reinstalled the same software, but sold it to the customer as a new, revised version.

If anyone has had similar experiences, I would be happy to read about them.

Greetings.
Thomas.
-----------------------------------------------------
Golf 3 TDI AFN Bj. 1997 -verkauft
Audi S2 ADU Bj. 1993
Polo 86c 2F 1W Bj. 1994 - verkauft
Audi A3 TDI ASZ Bj. 2001


Translated on 06-11-2026, 22:58.
Back to top Profile PM
DocSnydor
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post23-05-2003, 11:53    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

I think my pig whistles icon_wink.gif icon_twisted.gif.

That's quite something! You could almost think that you had your car tuned up at the bakery down the street... icon_evil.gif
What did you ultimately have to pay for the fun?
Was I'm wondering is, was that AFN originally installed in the car? It's surprising that you still have 4-hole wheels...

By the way: A passage in your story repeats itself once... icon_smile.gif


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:07.
Back to top
Thomas
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/17/2002
Posts: 329
Karma: +2 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Darmstadt

Support

Post23-05-2003, 16:29    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Hi Doc,

Yes, my Air Fryer Nacho (AFN) has always been in this car. The one with the four holes is perfectly normal.

It cost me 802.22 euros, icon_evil.gif without a warranty and without an ABE (German approval certificate).

The repetition is happening because this was a Word document, and an error occurred during the copy process. icon_redface.gif

@joergs

No. They made it so fat that it smokes like an old steam locomotive.
Fortunately, the fun mode can be switched off, so I can still drive with the standard software. However, I haven't achieved the tuning I wanted. So, I adjusted the injection time to match the opening pressure and compensated for the larger hole diameter due to the poorer atomization.

The car, although already fast with 153 horsepower and 370 Nm of torque, simply wasn't what I was looking for. I mean, what positive aspects does it even have? Suddenly, the high beam flash from a tailgater behind you seems so... insignificant. icon_wink.gif

Greetings.
Thomas.
-----------------------------------------------------
Golf 3 TDI AFN Bj. 1997 -verkauft
Audi S2 ADU Bj. 1993
Polo 86c 2F 1W Bj. 1994 - verkauft
Audi A3 TDI ASZ Bj. 2001


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:09.
Back to top Profile PM
joop
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post23-05-2003, 19:46    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

hello!

Well, that doesn't exactly sound very positive!

I actually find it a shame that customers still have to experience things like that.
When you compare the price to the performance, it's actually outrageous.

You've caught those typical tuners again, who simply increase the values by a percentage without much thought.
Does anyone have a different opinion...? Well, you can see it.

I hope there will be some positive news about chip tuners again.

Sure, here is the translation of the text from German to English:

'cu' is a Spanish abbreviation for 'con usted,' which means 'with you.' It is often used in online communication to indicate that the sender is available to chat or talk.

Here is an example of how 'cu' might be used in a conversation:

Person A: 'Hey, I'm bored. Want to chat?'
Person B: 'Cu!'

This means that Person B is available to chat with Person A.

'Cu' can also be used to indicate that the sender is thinking about the recipient. For example, if Person A sends a message to Person B and then receives a reply that says 'cu,' it could mean that Person B is thinking about Person A and wants to connect with them.

Overall, 'cu' is a versatile abbreviation that can be used in a variety of ways. It is a common way to indicate availability, interest, or affection in online communication.


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:12.
Back to top
kenny
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post23-05-2003, 20:00    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

You have a money-back guarantee with that company, right? Demand your money back and go to a different tuner.

If they refuse, the money-back guarantee is certainly documented somewhere in writing. Therefore, it is legally enforceable, and you can invoke your legal protection insurance if they object (if you don't have one, they won't know icon_wink.gif).


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:13.
Back to top
kenny
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post24-05-2003, 9:09    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

'That's probably closer to 280 Nm at 2100 RPM. Is the blue curve representing power, and the red one torque?'
But why is the peak torque so late, and not at 1900 RPM? And why is there such a fluctuation? It goes up, then down a bit, then stays at a lower level for a while, and then goes up again...


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:14.
Back to top
ulf
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/13/2002
Posts: 11058
Karma: +18 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Saarland
2023 MG ZS
Premium Support

Post24-05-2003, 10:00    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Thomas wrote:
My concern was to adjust the software to the large nozzles of the T4 Caravelle with 110 kW.


Hi Thomas,

Could it be that you, too, have fallen victim to the misconception that "turbo swaps without chip tuning won't work"?
You should have already noticed the increased performance when using the larger nozzles. What specific result from the software tuning were you expecting?
Or were there any problems operating the car after the injectors were installed?
Incidentally, this shouldn't be taken as flirting icon_wink.gif, because I've encountered such views before.
Therefore, the technical article on nozzles has also been updated accordingly.

Quote:
They made it so fat that it smokes like an old locomotive.
Fortunately, the fun mode can be switched off, so I can also drive with the standard software. However, I don't have the tuning I wanted. So, I adjusted the injection time to match the opening pressure and compensated for the larger hole diameter due to the poorer atomization.


Generally, the standard software also automatically adjusts the (unregulated!) subsequent start of injection back to the normal target value, as long as the pump settings provide the necessary range for injection adjustment.
Therefore, adjusting the opening pressure should ideally be done by setting the pump to a slightly earlier start time.
However, you don't have to spend a fortune with a chip tuner for that.
The poorer atomization cannot be compensated for by any further electronic adjustments.

But to expect something like that from a tuner who (still) doesn't even understand how the jet swap tuning works, that's bound to backfire icon_evil.gif.
For him, it's more important to extract money from a customer, even if their actual main request is completely unachievable.
As I said, don't take it personally! icon_wink.gif

Quote:
The car is already quite fast with 153 horsepower and 370 Nm of torque, but that simply wasn't what I was looking for.


I'm not entirely convinced about the 370 Nm figure. Going from 280 Nm (with the larger injectors without chip tuning) to 370 Nm would be almost a 25% increase, and at that point, the (standard) clutch would likely start to slip... not to mention the overall durability (e.g., head gasket, etc.).

Quote:
I mean, what positive thing does that have? The high beam from a tailgater behind you suddenly seems so... meaningless. icon_wink.gif


Because the bumper is getting smaller, or because the high beam indicator is barely visible due to the soot icon_twisted.gif?
Gruß Ulf
_________

MG4 Electric


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:17.
Back to top Profile PM Garage
Thomas
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/17/2002
Posts: 329
Karma: +2 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Darmstadt

Support

Post24-05-2003, 22:45    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Hi everyone,

da habt Ihr Euch aber mit dem Schreiben angestengt. J.

@kenny

Quote:
Don't you have a money-back guarantee with that company?
Demand your money back and go to a different tuner...

If they refuse, the money-back guarantee is certainly documented somewhere in writing. Therefore, it is legally enforceable, and you can invoke your legal protection insurance if they object (if you don't have one, they won't know). icon_smile.gif

"No way, not really. That would mean removing the module from the control unit, reversing everything, etc. I don't want to go to any tuners anymore. I can find other ways to waste my money."

Meanwhile, things don't look quite the same anymore. It's so that no one can dare to go out on the street. It's a shame that I don't have any pictures of this soot wall.
Quote:


@tim27

icon_lol.gif so, according to your performance chart, you have 131 horsepower and...
---388Nm at 380U/min???????
Could it be that the wrong gear was used????
Quote:


No. Those are errors from the test bench. For some reason, it's producing very strange readings below the idle speed. Don't ask me, I was just told that.

But about the elevator. I asked which floor they were going to. The answer was that it didn't matter. But it was the 4th floor.

@Ulf

Could it be that you, too, have fallen victim to the misconception that "turbo swaps without chip tuning don't work"? icon_rolleyes.gif

No. I knew it was possible. After all, she had already done it before, and I had spent far too much time dealing with the issue.
Quote:


You should have already noticed that the increased performance
Quote:
only comes with the larger nozzles.

I experienced this and described it in my previous thread about injector swaps. The results were almost entirely positive. It was similar to a tuning box, but without the soot.

What specific outcome of the software vote were you expecting? icon_cool.gif

The expected result is difficult to define. If you want to hear a "horsepower result" now, I don't have one. I am aware that other Austrian companies are able to extract more than 160 horsepower from similar TDI engines using just injectors and software, but I actually wanted to be surprised in that regard. icon_wink.gif
I was expecting a dyno test, which would essentially mean getting a new software tune for my engine. Even over the phone, they told me that it could take a very long time, but my main concern was actually the durability.
Please, let's avoid any fundamental discussions regarding durability and tuning. I already understand how they relate to each other. Then there was also this small part of curiosity...
Quote:



Or were there any problems during the operation of the car after the installation of the nozzles?
Quote:


No, quite the opposite. These things have only brought advantages, aside from the hole they've made in my wallet.

This is not intended to be flirtatious, as I have encountered such opinions before.
Quote:


Can I relate this to myself, or is it more general?

In principle, the standard software also regulates the (unregulated!) subsequent start of injection back to the normal target value, as long as the pump setting provides the necessary range for injection adjustment.
Therefore, adjusting the opening pressure should ideally be done by setting the pump to a slightly earlier start time.
However, you don't have to spend a fortune at a chip tuner for that.
The poorer atomization, in any case, cannot be compensated for by any further electronic tuning.
Quote:


And what about the fuel injection amount at idle?

You can't really expect that kind of tuner, who (still) doesn't even understand how jet replacement tuning works, to deliver good results; it's bound to backfire.
For him, it's more important to squeeze every last penny out of a customer, even if their actual main request is completely unrealistic.
As I said, don't take it personally!
Quote:


Ja, toll! Hinterher ist man immer schlauer. J.

How was I supposed to know beforehand that this mechanic had absolutely no idea about this engine swap or even about diesel engines? Over the phone, they seemed credible and professional. Besides, there are enough reports in the press and through word-of-mouth that support these claims. That's why I didn't really have any reason to doubt their statements. If they said they knew what they were doing and that it wouldn't be a problem, what indication could have convinced me otherwise?

But I didn't want to evoke any sympathy here, I just wanted to share "my experiences."
I don't want to deny that they, in my opinion, misled me, and that I fully fell for it... do I need to write anything more?

Solving the "problems" that arose from this is the easiest thing to do. But that's not the "point" of this post either!

I don't quite believe those 370 Nm: 280 Nm (with the large injectors without chip tuning) to 370 would be an increase of almost 25%, and the (standard) clutch would probably slip... not to mention the overall durability (head gasket, etc.).
Quote:


"The standard clutch has been gone from cars for a long time. Currently, I'm using a complete clutch from a G60, which starts to slip around 2000 RPM. But I agree with you, 370 Nm doesn't seem right. I wouldn't be surprised if... but those are just assumptions. Maybe I'll take my Golf to a Bosch service center and have them measure it. The results shouldn't be too different."

I'm also curious to see what the pistons look like.

Is it because the bumper is getting smaller, or because the high beam indicator is barely visible due to the soot? icon_wink.gif

More likely, it's the issue with the soot! }

Greetings.
Thomas.
-----------------------------------------------------
Golf 3 TDI AFN Bj. 1997 -verkauft
Audi S2 ADU Bj. 1993
Polo 86c 2F 1W Bj. 1994 - verkauft
Audi A3 TDI ASZ Bj. 2001


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:28.
Back to top Profile PM
ulf
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/13/2002
Posts: 11058
Karma: +18 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Saarland
2023 MG ZS
Premium Support

Post25-05-2003, 8:08    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Thomas wrote:

Quote:
This is not intended to be flirtatious, as I have encountered such opinions before.

Can I apply this to myself, or is it more general?


Hi Thomas,

with "öfters", I meant "by various people" icon_sad.gif.

Quote:
Quote:
The poorer atomization, in any case, can no longer be compensated for by any electronic tuning.

And what about the fuel injection amount at idle?


The idle speed is primarily controlled by regulating the engine RPM, "regardless" of how much fuel is injected.
If the perceived amount becomes too low, jerking problems occur --> Nozzle technical articles.

Quote:
How was I supposed to know beforehand that this tuner had absolutely no idea about this engine swap or even about diesel engines? Over the phone, they seemed credible and appeared professional to me. Moreover, there are enough reports in the press and through word-of-mouth that support these statements. That's why I didn't really have a reason to doubt their statements to that extent. If they said they knew about it and that it wasn't a problem, what indication could have convinced me otherwise?


Good question, next question...
I didn't want to say "you should have foreseen that because..." - because that's where I would have run out of arguments.
Unless you had already been able to peek behind the scenes of the tuner you were targeting. But who can do that? icon_sad.gif icon_question.gif


Quote:
I don't want to deny that they, in my opinion, led me astray, and that I fully went along with it... do I need to write anything more?


No, that was overly explicit - and I can imagine that it hurt you to write that again.
Respect, not everyone could have done that. icon_exclaim.gif icon_smile.gif
Gruß Ulf
_________

MG4 Electric


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:37.
Back to top Profile PM Garage
Thomas
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/17/2002
Posts: 329
Karma: +2 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Darmstadt

Support

Post25-05-2003, 15:10    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Hi Ulf,

Quote:
When I said "oftentimes," I meant "by various people."


Then I understand what you mean.

Quote:
The idle speed is primarily controlled by the engine speed, "regardless" of how much fuel is injected.
If the perceived amount becomes too low, jerking problems occur -> see nozzle-related technical articles.


If the amount is too low, these jerking problems occur, or the engine may even stall completely. But what if the amount is simply too high?

Quote:

Good question, next question...
I didn't want to say "you should have foreseen that because..." - because that's where I would have run out of arguments.
Unless you had a chance to peek behind the scenes of the tuner you were targeting beforehand. But who can do that?


Exactly. Unfortunately. But thankfully, there are ways to protect yourself. icon_wink.gif

I know there are people who have had similar experiences. It would be good if all of this could be collected somewhere.

Greetings.
Thomas.
-----------------------------------------------------
Golf 3 TDI AFN Bj. 1997 -verkauft
Audi S2 ADU Bj. 1993
Polo 86c 2F 1W Bj. 1994 - verkauft
Audi A3 TDI ASZ Bj. 2001


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:41.
Back to top Profile PM
ulf
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/13/2002
Posts: 11058
Karma: +18 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Saarland
2023 MG ZS
Premium Support

Post25-05-2003, 15:19    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Thomas wrote:


Quote:
The idle speed is primarily controlled by the engine speed, "regardless" of how much fuel is injected.
If the perceived amount becomes too low, it can lead to surging problems --> Nozzle technical articles.


If the amount is too low, these jerking problems occur, or the engine may even stall completely. But what if the amount is simply too high?


Hi Thomas,

There probably still some issues to be understood regarding the idle speed control.

For example, if the engine speed is too high, the MSW (Motor Speed Limiter) will reduce the speed until it reaches 900 rpm, and vice versa.
The motor computer converts the RWG voltage reported by the pump at 900 rpm into a "calculated" injection amount, which may not correspond to the actual injection amount at all.

If the fuel pump is set too rich (or if large injectors with a low opening pressure are installed), even a slight deviation in the MSW (Engine Control Unit) for the idle fuel quantity at 9000 rpm can be enough – the engine computer believes it is injecting a correspondingly small amount of fuel.
"And that's precisely where, based on experience, you're likely to encounter jerking or hesitation, especially under partial load conditions -> error database: DIY solutions for reducing jerking."
Gruß Ulf
_________

MG4 Electric


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:44.
Back to top Profile PM Garage
Arne
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post26-05-2003, 8:14    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Which tuner are we talking about now? Or did I miss something?

I don't see a problem with posting the name here. Praising words are allowed, but apparently, even well-founded criticism is not?

Regards,
arne


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:46.
Back to top
Thomas
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/17/2002
Posts: 329
Karma: +2 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Darmstadt

Support

Post26-05-2003, 10:48    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Hi,

@Ulf

Yes, I agree with you. I understand what you mean.

You write:
Quote:
... (or possibly large nozzles with low opening pressure installed), ...


How should the lower opening pressure be understood? The AFN nozzles open at 190 bar, while the AXG/AHY nozzles only open at 220 bar. Doesn't that mean the opening pressure is higher in the latter case?

If the "calculated" injection amount doesn't match the actual injection amount, but the engine speed is kept constant at approximately 900 RPM, what is the exhaust quality like at that moment, for example, if too much diesel is injected? Can this problem be mitigated by reducing the calculated injection amount using a map, so that the injector closes even further and the actual injection amount also decreases? Or would this also cause the engine speed to decrease?

@Arne

You have a private message.

Greetings.
Thomas.

[/quote]
-----------------------------------------------------
Golf 3 TDI AFN Bj. 1997 -verkauft
Audi S2 ADU Bj. 1993
Polo 86c 2F 1W Bj. 1994 - verkauft
Audi A3 TDI ASZ Bj. 2001


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:47.
Back to top Profile PM
gaspedaluser
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post26-05-2003, 12:52    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Hello,

@Arne

You have a private message.

What's with all the secrecy? If you don't tell us where it was, people can only feel sorry for you. It doesn't benefit anyone to keep it a secret!

Does the injection amount also decrease? Or does the engine speed also decrease then?
A diesel engine operates according to the principle of quality control. I actually find it confusing when the terms 'rich' and 'lean' are often used in this context, as these terms are actually used for gasoline engines. Simply put, in a diesel engine: more/less fuel results in more/less torque, or more/less RPM. The amount of air remains constant, depending on various factors (e.g., RPM, boost pressure, etc.) (no throttling). The injection pressure doesn't matter, as long as the fuel quantity control system still has enough range. The EDC simply regulates the 900 RPM and that's it!

Greetings.


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:50.
Back to top
Stefan
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post26-05-2003, 15:05    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

I agree. If you want to warn us, then tell us who we should be warned about... icon_rolleyes.gif

Constructive criticism is not a bad thing.


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:51.
Back to top
ulf
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/13/2002
Posts: 11058
Karma: +18 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Saarland
2023 MG ZS
Premium Support

Post26-05-2003, 16:29    Subject: Chip Tuning: Reviews & Experiences Quote

Thomas wrote:
Yes, I agree with you. I understand what you mean
.

Hi Thomas,

It seems there's still a catch when it comes to understanding.

Quote:
If the "calculated" injection amount does not match the actual injection amount, but the ~900 RPM is kept constant, what is the exhaust quality like at that moment, for example, if too much diesel is injected? Can this problem be mitigated by reducing the calculated injection amount via a map, so that the MSW closes further and the actual injection amount also decreases? Or would the RPM then also decrease?


That's exactly what's happening!
And if "too much" diesel is injected, the idle speed (initially) increases icon_exclaim.gif.
But then the priority of the speed setting kicks in again -> the amount [of something] is reduced until the speed reaches 900 rpm.
And the exhaust emissions are the same (with the same injection timing), as if the engine control unit is reporting the "normal" idle fuel quantity.

If the engine control unit (ECU) reports extremely low fuel injection amounts during idle, the idle will become erratic (making a "cluck-cluck-cluck" sound).

By modifying the fuel map, one can at best eliminate jerking problems, but not change the actual fuel injection amount at idle (as long as the engine speed is 900 rpm and the injection timing is not adjusted).

Quote:

You write:
Quote:
... (or possibly large nozzles with low opening pressure installed), ...


How should the low opening pressure be understood? The AFN nozzles open at 190 bar, while the AXG/AHY nozzles only open at 220 bar. Doesn't that mean the opening pressure is higher?


I meant larger nozzles with the same low opening pressure as the standard ones.
For example, replacing 1Z nozzles with 190 bar pressure with AFN nozzles with 190 bar pressure.
Sorry, I expressed myself awkwardly. icon_redface.gif
Gruß Ulf
_________

MG4 Electric


Translated on 06-11-2026, 23:54.
Back to top Profile PM Garage
New Topic Reply 🔗 ⭐ 🖨 Dieselschrauber - Index » Diesel Engine Technology
Go to page: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
Similar articles and topics
Topic Forum
No new posts Chip Tuning Companies List Diesel Engine Technology
No new posts Chiptuning Thüringen: Reliable Chip Tuning Specialists Diesel Engine Technology
No new posts [Poll] OT: Experiences with eBay Transmission, Chassis, Body & Interior
No new posts Experiences with 150 PD and p-Box Diesel Engine Technology
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum.