| Author |
Message |
vagtuning Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
13-07-2003, 8:44 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Hi,
The Touran and the A3 models with a 2.0L TDI engine are completely incompatible with rapeseed methyl ester (RME).
Furthermore, there is absolutely no warranty or goodwill offered when using biofuel. In vehicles that come to the workshop with problems and suspected of containing RME, a fuel sample is taken and sent to the laboratory for analysis. There are apparently two data blocks that need to be read out, and if they don't meet the required values, a sample is sent to the factory. If the analysis is positive, any additional payment will be completely rejected.
Is this stuff really so completely unsuitable for cars? I think that's probably more related to the tax classification and the production conditions for RME, which aren't really guaranteed in Germany!
Chrisi.
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:18.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
WarLord Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
13-07-2003, 9:25 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
First, there's the issue of the uncertain quality of biodiesel, which shouldn't be as big of a problem anymore. However, the real problem is that VW has finally realized that Bosch doesn't approve its fuel injection pumps for use with RME. This is because RME is slightly corrosive to the pump and the lines.
Best regards, WarLord.
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:20.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Bertil Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 04/15/2002 Posts: 5628 Karma: +108 / -0
Premium Support
|
13-07-2003, 9:50 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
HI,
WarLord wrote: | First, there's the issue of the unsecured quality of the biofuel, which shouldn't be as big of a problem anymore. The problem lies more in the fact that VW has finally realized that Bosch doesn't approve its fuel injection pumps for use with RME. RME is slightly corrosive to the pump and the lines.
|
Almost got it!
The consumer protection law has changed (and VW has now realized this), and in cases of damage, the supplier is initially responsible for providing proof, not the customer (as was previously the case). For BD (presumably referring to a specific fuel or product), this means that VW now has to prove that the fuel caused the damage. However, if VW approves the fuel, it becomes difficult to prove its responsibility. Therefore, they are now immediately banning the product, thus avoiding any potential liability.
By the way, the BD (presumably referring to a specific component or feature) is no longer allowed in the AXR engine in the Touran either (despite the same mechanics)!
Gruß Bertil
Skoda 5E5 CZDA + Mini R50 W10 + VW ID.3 + Fiat Ducato 250 + 161 DX
*** Technische Anfragen per PN werden von mir nicht beantwortet! ***
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:21.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
Julian Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
13-07-2003, 10:07 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Okay, my AWX from 5/03 is approved for BD (Biodiesel); even the factory-installed auxiliary heater can handle it.
I will not try it. The PD doesn't really need much branded gasoline anyway! 
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:23.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
D. Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
13-07-2003, 16:41 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
How do you mean that about 'basically not needing much branded gasoline'?
Best regards, D., who still wants to try out some basic vegetable oil from ALDI.
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:23.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Julian Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
13-07-2003, 18:57 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
'That means it runs very economically with Araldiesel, Deadiesel, etc. The fuel-saving effect, for me, is more about my driving style than the rapeseed-based fuel, which is why I don't use it.  I can't actually save that much with it.  '
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:24.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
WarLord Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
13-07-2003, 18:59 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
And you're not harming the state if you don't buy rapeseed methyl ester (or is biodiesel no longer subsidized?).
Best regards, WarLord.
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:24.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Julian Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
13-07-2003, 19:37 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
And you are not harming the state if you don't buy RME (or is biodiesel no longer subsidized?).
Greetings, WarLord.
Hey, I'm already indulging in the luxury of not smoking. Somehow, I have to help protect our country from further debt, and I dutifully pay 73 cents in tax per liter. (I think it was less for diesel... I have no idea).
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:25.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
WarLord Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
14-07-2003, 10:34 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Oh, are you also one of those people who don't smoke (like me)?
Best regards, WarLord.
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:25.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Jürgen Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
14-07-2003, 12:17 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Hello,
I saw a small article in the Frankfurter Rundschau newspaper on Saturday.
Read articles on the topic. The approval is supposedly due to this.
not yet implemented, as an EU standard for Renewable Mounting Elements is currently being prepared.
and the Volkswagen Group, which is still waiting for it. According to this article,
Will Volkswagen continue to adhere to the policy of phasing out all diesel engines?
to be released for RME.
For my part, I mostly use biodiesel, but I also pay attention to...
darauf nur einen zuverlässigen Lieferanten zu haben! Absolutely so far.
Seamlessly.
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:26.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Bertil Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 04/15/2002 Posts: 5628 Karma: +108 / -0
Premium Support
|
14-07-2003, 12:37 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Hello,
Jürgen wrote: | ...
The approval is supposedly due to...
not yet implemented, as an EU standard for Renewable Mounting Elements is currently being prepared.
and the Volkswagen Group, which is still waiting for it.
... |
I hope I don't run out of breath from laughing!
There has never been an EU standard for BD (presumably referring to a specific technology or component). Nevertheless, VW approved its engines for "standard-compliant" BD (in contrast to the suppliers of the affected components). VW's excuse regarding the non-standard BD has historically put the customer at a disadvantage in cases of damages. The new law on damages now reverses the burden of proof. Now, VW is simply panicking and shutting things down.
However, I can confirm your rendition of the newspaper article.
http://www.spiegel.de/auto/werkstatt/0,1518,254679,00.html
Quote: | | Audi spokesperson Rügheimer cites quality problems of biodiesel producers as the reason for the new restraint. Since RME is produced in Germany by many different oil mills, a uniform fuel quality has not yet been guaranteed. However, the new diesel engines are sensitive to quality differences. Furthermore, biodiesel, when mixed with normal diesel, can dissolve deposits that may be present in the fuel system. |
However, in my opinion, this is not a problem specific to newer TDIs, but rather a problem affecting all diesel vehicles!
Quote: | | Furthermore, the Audi spokesperson stated that "it is not guaranteed that the very strict Euro 4 emission standard can be met with biodiesel" | .
Great saying!
Here's a quote from http://www.biodiesel.de/abgas.htm:.
Quote: | The fuel itself also has a significant impact on exhaust emissions. Biodiesel offers clear advantages over conventional diesel fuel in terms of HC, CO, and particulate matter.
As the following figure shows, a EURO-II engine running on biodiesel already nearly meets the particle emission limits for EURO-III. Furthermore, the positive effect of biodiesel becomes even more pronounced when an oxidation catalyst is additionally installed.
|
Unfortunately, this page completely omits the NOx values  .
In my opinion, the poorer viscosity of Biodiesel (BD) is a problem for modern High-Definition (HD) injection systems. Fuel with a higher viscosity, like BD, increases the stress on the fuel pump (ZR)! Therefore, the viscosity is no longer mentioned on the BD product information (see http://www.biodiesel.de/deutsch.htm).
Gruß Bertil
Skoda 5E5 CZDA + Mini R50 W10 + VW ID.3 + Fiat Ducato 250 + 161 DX
*** Technische Anfragen per PN werden von mir nicht beantwortet! ***
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:30.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
Ben1972 Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
16-07-2003, 13:27 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
It is absolutely correct that the viscosity of RME puts more strain on the pump(s). However, this is also addressed during testing, so it doesn't pose a problem. What is more interesting is how much benefit there really is when using RME. At first glance, it seems cheaper. But: fuel consumption increases, and the filter element needs to be replaced more often because RME simply contains more dirt particles. Furthermore, the engine's power decreases by about 5%. Not to mention the carbon buildup on the injection elements and the poor starting behavior even at temperatures around 0°C.
In my opinion, you really have to be extremely environmentally conscious to use this fuel! And even then, you have to calculate whether it's really worth it for the environment, considering you have to replace the filter every 30,000 km!!!
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:34.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Jürgen Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
16-07-2003, 15:01 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Hello Ben 1972,
ich habe im letzten Winter durchgehend RME gefahren. As we all know.
It was known that, at times last winter, the temperature was significantly below 0°C!
Even at -15°C, both of my vehicles started up perfectly.
(Lantern parking in the countryside!) and my diesel filters are...
It's been a while now!
One thing in this forum is starting to annoy me a bit. As soon as the topic of biodiesel, RME, or something similar comes up, a lot of...
strange comments. Sometimes I get the impression that...
Many people did not have a great childhood because...
Comments are often very ideologically one-sided and critical of RME (Rechtsmedizin) etc., sometimes.
sogar beleidigend (Ich meine jetzt nicht dich, Ben1972!). IMO would be a...
A more friendly atmosphere in such a forum would be desirable!
I will also be following the development of the new synthetic additives (BIOTROL).
Observe very carefully. I would be willing to pay a few extra cents for that.
already be willing to accept. These technologies create jobs in the...
The BRD (Federal Republic of Germany) is helping to reduce our dependence on oil imports.
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:36.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Uli S. Schrauber

Joined: 07/02/2003 Posts: 338 Karma: +7 / -0 Location: Äußerster Südwesten
Support
|
16-07-2003, 17:20 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Hello Jürgen,
Quote: | One thing in this forum is starting to annoy me a bit. As soon as the topic of biodiesel, RME, or something similar comes up, a lot of...
strange comments. Sometimes I get the impression that...
Many people did not have a great childhood because...
Comments are often very ideologically one-sided and critical of RME, etc. |
Well, a forum kind of reflects the society we live in. Try explaining to a Schalke fan why Dortmund is much better (okay, that's a huge stretch). Many people have an opinion on a topic, and they express it, more or less emotionally and stubbornly. And the topic of cars is something that every "real man"  has an opinion on. Sometimes, complete nonsense is said and defended, even to the point of threats of violence  .
Quote: | I will also be following the development of the new synthetic active ingredients (BIOTROL).
Observe very carefully. I would be willing to pay a few extra cents for that.
already be willing to accept. These technologies create jobs in the...
The BRD (Federal Republic of Germany) and help to somewhat alleviate the dependence on oil imports | .
Here are some of the reasons why I think Pöl is so great (by the way, soy costs 59 cents/liter right now, while used Pöl is free), and as long as my old centrifugal pumps don't break down, I'll continue to use and maintain them. If I ever get a TDI engine, it will probably have to run on this stuff somehow.
Biodiesel (RME) is, in my opinion, the wrong approach: it has a worse CO2 and energy balance, it's corrosive, it reduces performance and/or increases fuel consumption, and the oil companies are making a fortune thanks to subsidies. However, the government could easily introduce a tax on it at any time once it becomes established (I'm sure I've forgotten something). The only disadvantage of regular diesel compared to RME is its higher viscosity, but it's not that dramatic. My girlfriend and I drove all winter long on pure diesel (even at -11°C) without adding any diesel or other additives.
Peaceful greetings.
Uli (who thinks biodiesel is good for cleaning dirty engine parts because it doesn't smell as bad as diesel).
Golf2 GTD AAZ, LLK, CYP
Bus T3 JX
Passat 32B SB, LLK, Garett T2, 2N
2x Golf2 GTD/SB
alle fahren/fuhren ganzjährig frauentauglich mit 100% Pflanzenöl
97er Golf 3 AFN, 70-100% Pöl
97er Golf 3 Variant AFN
96er Passat 35i AFN
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:40.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
eike Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
16-07-2003, 19:24 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Hi everyone,
There's already been a preliminary standard or something similar for biodiesel for quite some time. At least, that's what's posted at every biodiesel pump where I refuel. I'm not clear why this draft or whatever it is hasn't been officially adopted as a standard.
Perhaps we should check with our consumer protection minister, Renate K.
Ultimately, I see it this way: If I refuel with something that is supposed to meet standard X, and I'm putting it into a vehicle that is designed to use fuels meeting that standard X, then what's the problem? If something then breaks down, it's either because the fuel didn't meet the standard, and the supplier must be held liable, or because the vehicle didn't live up to its promised performance, and the manufacturer must be held liable.
If you keep the fuel receipts for six months, it should be possible to provide a complete record of the origin without any problems. This should allow for a clear determination of liability in the event of a claim.
Regarding the viscosity of BD (Biodiesel), it is specified within the standard and is very close to that of diesel fuel. This is likely not the problem.
Since diesel fuel now contains even less sulfur, its lubricating effect has significantly decreased. I'm curious why no one seems to be complaining about this.
I believe this issue has a lot to do with lobbying. After all, a lot of money is involved...
Regards,
Eike.
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:44.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Bertil Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 04/15/2002 Posts: 5628 Karma: +108 / -0
Premium Support
|
16-07-2003, 19:29 Subject: Touran & A3 (8P): RME Incompatible - No Go! |
Quote |
|
Hi Jürgen,
Jürgen wrote: | One thing in this forum is starting to annoy me a bit. As soon as the topic of biodiesel, RME, or something similar comes up, a lot of...
Strange comments.
Sometimes I get the impression that...
Many people did not have a great childhood because...
Comments are often very ideologically one-sided and critical of RME (Rechtsmedizin) etc., sometimes.
sogar beleidigend (Ich meine jetzt nicht dich, Ben1972!). IMO would be a...
A more friendly atmosphere in such a forum would be desirable!
|
Since you specifically exclude Ben1972, I think you're referring to me.
I have not taken any position for or against RME, but I have critically examined what the biodiesel industry (and also Volkswagen) would prefer to keep hidden.
However, I am well aware of the corrosive properties of RME (Rapeseed Methyl Ester), so I find it hard to imagine that diesel manufacturers would quickly approve its use. RME certainly poses a problem in terms of its dependence on the petroleum industry. However, subsidies should be discontinued and the price of RME should be decoupled from the price of diesel, so that RME can either succeed in the free market or not. Then, the consumer can decide.
I find it very upsetting that you're bringing my childhood (and the childhoods of others) into this. This kind of thing doesn't belong in a technical forum.
Quote: |
I will also be following the development of the new synthetic additives (BIOTROL).
Observe very carefully. I would be willing to pay a few extra cents for that.
already be willing to accept. These technologies create jobs in the...
The BRD (Federal Republic of Germany) and help to somewhat alleviate the dependence on oil imports. |
I see it the same way.
"However, RME is the wrong approach - I agree with Uli S. and would much rather use PÖL than RME. I don't have much to say about BIOTROL yet, as I don't have much information about it."
Gruß Bertil
Skoda 5E5 CZDA + Mini R50 W10 + VW ID.3 + Fiat Ducato 250 + 161 DX
*** Technische Anfragen per PN werden von mir nicht beantwortet! ***
Translated on 04-10-2026, 9:48.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
|