| Author |
Message |
Gilliearnie
Joined: 02/22/2012 Posts: 34 Karma: +2 / -0
2009 Volkswagen Polo Registered VCDS User
|
07-09-2012, 10:10 Subject: |
Quote |
|
You probably mean the software in the MSG, right?
I can't tell whether it's the original, but definitely nothing was changed during my time.
Is there a way to find this out, or do I need to install a different MSG?
I need to replace the AGR valve because it's no longer working.
When idling, the air mass reading is 450 mg/H, which should be around 250 mg/H.
The EGR valve control setting is at 84%, which to me suggests that the EGR valve is closed.
But I took the metal plate out again and connected the wires.
Therefore, the valve is not working; the pressure transducer is defective.
So, I need a new one before the next technical inspection, right? Or do you think it will pass without it?
Regarding the legend:
If you hover the mouse cursor slightly above the line, it will display the name, value, and timestamp. I usually remove this feature to make the chart a bit clearer and larger. But if you want to leave it on next time, that's no problem!
If you're also surprised by these values, what could be the cause? Could it be a leak in the pressure-reducing valve (PRV) element, or faulty valves? Or is the nozzle opening too large?
Because, in my opinion, a negative value indicates that the cylinder is producing too much power and is therefore being restricted, right?
So, the amount of fuel injected into that cylinder must be higher than for the other cylinders in order for it to produce that amount of power.
VW Caddy Maxi, 1,9l TDI BLS 6- Gang DSG
VW Polo 1,4l TDI BMS
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:19.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Garage |
 |
ulf Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 04/13/2002 Posts: 11058 Karma: +18 / -0 Location: Saarland 2023 MG ZS Premium Support
|
07-09-2012, 10:36 Subject: |
Quote |
|
Gilliearnie wrote: | You probably mean the software in the MSG, right?
I can't tell whether it's the original, but definitely nothing was changed during my time.
Can I find that out somehow, or do I need to install a different MSG? | It's not possible with common household tools. If you have access to a (tuner) flashing tool, you could read out the software and send it to me, for example, so I can compare it with the OEM factory software.
Otherwise, you would need to use a different MSG (WFS!) and test it, or obtain log data from another vehicle with the same MSG.
Quote: | I need to replace the EGR valve because it is no longer working.
When idling, the air mass reading is 450 mg/H, which should be around 250 mg/H.
The EGR valve control setting is at 84%, which to me suggests that the EGR valve is closed.
But I took the metal plate out again and connected the wires.
Therefore -> The valve is not switching, the pressure transducer is defective. | OK, I didn't review the logs for that.
It's possible that something is just stuck. With the angled tube removed, you could try gripping the valve stem with a pair of pliers and lifting it upwards against the closing force. You might hear a click, and then it might start working normally again.
Is the exhaust path from the exhaust manifold to the EGR valve clear? We don't want a carbon buildup blocking it, because even a new, expensive EGR valve won't work if there's an obstruction.
Quote: | | So, I need a new one before the next TÜV inspection, right? Or do you think it will pass like that? | As long as there are no errors in the error memory and the "readiness" status is set to "OK" (if that is already checked for your car / depending on the year of manufacture), you might even pass with a closed AGR valve.
Quote: | If these values also surprise you: What could it be? A leaking PDE element or valves? Or is the nozzle opening too large?
Because, IMHO, a negative value indicates that this cylinder is producing too much power and is therefore being throttled, right? | In principle, yes. However, if 3 cylinders are weak, they essentially force the one functioning cylinder into a negative value for no reason, because the sum of all cylinder data is always zero.
Quote: | | Therefore, the amount of fuel injected into that cylinder would have to be higher than for the other cylinders in order for it to achieve that performance. | Not necessarily, see above.
Gruß Ulf
_________
MG4 Electric
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:24.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Garage |
 |
Gilliearnie
Joined: 02/22/2012 Posts: 34 Karma: +2 / -0
2009 Volkswagen Polo Registered VCDS User
|
07-09-2012, 10:50 Subject: |
Quote |
|
Quote: | It's not possible to do this with common household tools. If you have access to a (tuner) flashing tool, you could read out the software and, for example, send it to me so that I can compare it with the OEM factory software.
Otherwise, you would need to use a different MSG (WFS!) and try it out, or obtain log data from another vehicle with the same MSG. |
Okay, so I unfortunately don't have access to a flashing tool...
Unfortunately, I don't have any measurement data from a comparable engine available right now. Also, I don't know anyone in my network who has the same engine.
Quote: | OK, I haven't reviewed the logs yet.
It's possible that something is just stuck. With the angled hose removed, you could try gripping the valve stem with a pair of pliers and lifting it upwards against the closing force. You might hear a click, and then it might start working normally again.
Is the exhaust path from the manifold to the EGR unit clear? | We don't want a carbon buildup blocking it, because even an expensive new EGR valve won't help if there's an obstruction. Quote: |
When I removed the AGR valve for cleaning, I tried to push it from the bottom with a screwdriver. It wasn't that easy; it was quite stuck. The spring force made it difficult to push the valve down.
But I will definitely look into the soot plug suggestion again.
| As long as there are no error codes stored and the readiness status is set to OK (if this is already checked on your model / depending on the year of manufacture), you should be able to pass the inspection even with a closed EGR valve. Quote: |
I have one manufactured in 10/2001, so it's one of the early models. It's not being monitored yet. Maybe I'll just try it and see what happens. I'll probably still have the TÜV (German technical inspection) done at my friend's workshop. If it doesn't work, he can just replace it right away. I think that's the best option.
| In principle, yes. However, if 3 cylinders are weak, they essentially force the one functioning cylinder into the negative range unnecessarily, because the sum of all cylinder data is always zero.}
Oh, but I thought it was more likely that a single cylinder would have a problem than that three cylinders (not necessarily related) would, for example, be leaking.
VW Caddy Maxi, 1,9l TDI BLS 6- Gang DSG
VW Polo 1,4l TDI BMS
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:30.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Garage |
 |
ulf Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 04/13/2002 Posts: 11058 Karma: +18 / -0 Location: Saarland 2023 MG ZS Premium Support
|
07-09-2012, 11:00 Subject: |
Quote |
|
Gilliearnie wrote: | Okay, so, unfortunately, I don't have access to a flashing tool...
And I don't currently have any measurement data from a comparable engine, unfortunately. | Also, I don't have anyone in my circle who has the same engine either. Quote: | Well, it's not a critical issue, as long as the engine doesn't revert to that state of instability after the point indicated in the log data.
| When I removed the EGR valve to clean it, I tried to push it from below with a screwdriver. It wasn't that easy; it was quite stuck, so the spring force made it difficult to push the valve. Quote: | Yes, the spring has quite a bit of force. However, as long as the valve stem is reasonably easy to move after overcoming the spring force, you don't have to forcefully break the closed valve open every time, and the EGR cooler doesn't have any leaks, I don't think there's a reason to replace the entire EGR unit.
| Oh, but I thought it was more likely that a single cylinder would have a problem than that three cylinders (not necessarily adjacent) would, for example, be leaking. } For instance, if the PDE of the strong cylinder was replaced by the previous owner, then 3 old cylinders and 1 new one are working together, presumably with better atomization. That could already provide an explanation.
Gruß Ulf
_________
MG4 Electric
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:34.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Garage |
 |
Gilliearnie
Joined: 02/22/2012 Posts: 34 Karma: +2 / -0
2009 Volkswagen Polo Registered VCDS User
|
07-09-2012, 11:35 Subject: |
Quote |
|
Quote: | | For example, if the PDE of the strong cylinder was replaced by the previous owner, then 3 old ones and 1 new one are working together, and the new one likely has better atomization. This could already provide an explanation. |
Yes, that's certainly a good question.
Is there a way to check this and find out?
Or can I rather disregard this for now and check again in six months to see if the values have changed?
PDE elements weren't necessarily the cheapest either...
When the car was in the workshop, the mechanic used a vacuum pump to apply suction to the AGR valve and said that it wasn't moving.
That's why I initially assumed the AGR (Abtgasrückführung) system was defective. (It just occurred to me while I was eating...)
I knew it was broken, but I also don't exactly remember why I know that... 
VW Caddy Maxi, 1,9l TDI BLS 6- Gang DSG
VW Polo 1,4l TDI BMS
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:36.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Garage |
 |
ulf Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 04/13/2002 Posts: 11058 Karma: +18 / -0 Location: Saarland 2023 MG ZS Premium Support
|
07-09-2012, 20:01 Subject: |
Quote |
|
Gilliearnie wrote: | Quote: | | For example, if the PDE of the strong cylinder was replaced by the previous owner, then 3 old ones and 1 new one are working together, presumably with better atomization. This could already provide an explanation. | Yes, that is of course a good question.
Is there a way to check this and find out?
Or can you rather ignore this and check again in six months to see if the values have changed? | That's how I would do it.
Quote: | When the car was in the workshop, the mechanic used a pump to create a vacuum on the AGR valve and said that it didn't move.
Therefore, I initially assumed that the AGR (Abgasrückführungssystem - exhaust gas recirculation system) was defective. (It just occurred to me while I was eating...)
I knew it was broken, but I don't exactly remember why I knew that anymore...  | It's better not to trust any workshop for defect diagnoses if you can check the thing yourself. 
Gruß Ulf
_________
MG4 Electric
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:39.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Garage |
 |
Gilliearnie
Joined: 02/22/2012 Posts: 34 Karma: +2 / -0
2009 Volkswagen Polo Registered VCDS User
|
07-09-2012, 20:17 Subject: |
Quote |
|
Okay, then I'll leave it as it is for now.
I have saved values so that I can always find them again...
I've now sealed the AGR again with a plate.
And the two hoses from the EGR valve and the AK (likely referring to an air intake component) were disconnected and sealed.
I'm going to continue driving like this for now and see if I experience the loss of power again.
But it's highly likely that it was the AK.
Thank you all for your help, and I will get back to you as soon as the error occurs again.
VW Caddy Maxi, 1,9l TDI BLS 6- Gang DSG
VW Polo 1,4l TDI BMS
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:40.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Garage |
 |
Herbert Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 06/22/2005 Posts: 4636 Karma: +1350 / -0
Premium Support
|
08-09-2012, 10:26 Subject: |
Quote |
|
Hi there.
The AGR (Abgasrückführung - exhaust gas recirculation) should be checkable with VCDS when the engine is idling (if the MSG - Motor Steuergerät - engine control unit - provides this functionality).
- Perform actuator diagnostics up to and including the EGR valve.
- Exit actuator diagnosis;
- Access measurement data blocks;
- In MWB 3, observe the switching of the duty cycle and the target and actual values of the air mass. The duty cycle and air mass should oscillate between the minimum and maximum values.
- then select "actuator diagnosis" again;
- Complete the actuator diagnosis (that's what the control module requires).
This is a basic functional test of the AGR valve. However, it doesn't guarantee that the valve will close completely under higher engine loads.
hg
Herbert.
Horch A4 8K CJCD
Golf 7 DDYA
(+ Audi 80 Avant B4 1Z 475Tkm - habe ich vom ersten bis zum letzten Tag gerne gefahren)
(+ Passat Variant 32B CY 400Tkm)
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:42.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
ulf Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 04/13/2002 Posts: 11058 Karma: +18 / -0 Location: Saarland 2023 MG ZS Premium Support
|
08-09-2012, 14:29 Subject: |
Quote |
|
Herbert wrote: | - Perform actuator diagnostics up to and including the EGR valve.
- Exit actuator diagnosis;
- Access measurement data blocks;
- In MWB 3, observe the switching of the duty cycle and the target and actual values of the air mass; the duty cycle and air mass should switch back and forth between the min/max values. | Is it really possible to exit the actuator diagnosis without the MSG ending the back-and-forth switching?
I haven't specifically tried this yet, but it seems somewhat exotic: if you were to do this, for example, using the VTG actuator diagnostics and then try to start driving quickly, you would experience an extreme "camel driver" acceleration  .
To observe the AGR function, I would normally access the MWB 3 menu and then select the basic settings. This will open and close the AGR, and you can log the data.
Gruß Ulf
_________
MG4 Electric
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:44.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Garage |
 |
Herbert Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 06/22/2005 Posts: 4636 Karma: +1350 / -0
Premium Support
|
08-09-2012, 15:16 Subject: |
Quote |
|
You need to re-enter the actuator diagnostics, and continue and complete the process.
The MSG remembers the status of the actuator diagnosis and resumes where it was previously interrupted. You cannot simply start the process without any prior setup.
It works with the fuel injector control, and it's even described in the RLF (presumably a technical manual). I specifically tested it with the AGR (presumably an actuator), and I'm sure it works with other actuators as well (although my Audi doesn't have them).
Sure, here's the translation:
"Best regards," or "Sincerely,".
Herbert.
Horch A4 8K CJCD
Golf 7 DDYA
(+ Audi 80 Avant B4 1Z 475Tkm - habe ich vom ersten bis zum letzten Tag gerne gefahren)
(+ Passat Variant 32B CY 400Tkm)
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:46.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
floriankon Blaumann

Joined: 12/29/2002 Posts: 12 Karma: +6 / -0 Location: österreich
Free account, no CAN development support
|
03-07-2019, 6:11 Subject: Problem solved? Get help now! |
Quote |
|
I'm experiencing the same symptoms, and I've tried everything.
Translated on 31-10-2026, 16:47.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM Email |
 |
|