| Author |
Message |
neubaupe Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
07-10-2008, 13:12 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
The control unit calculates the value based on the load state,
whether it corresponds to the driver's desired acceleration (pedal position).
The injection amount can be released.
adapt it as necessary below.
This is the injection quantity per cylinder (available in VAG-COM).
(To see measurement block  is one of the...
Input parameters for consumption calculation.
Then we have speed and velocity.
From this, the current consumption can be determined.
calculated and also extrapolated to a distance of 100 km.
will be.
Whether the advertisement is accurate now depends on...
'how the specified injection amount is related to...'
the actual amount injected.
'I agree, and that is partly related to...'
Condition of the nozzles, and whether they are original nozzles.
are ...
And the condition of the high-pressure piston in the pump, correct?
Von kann die Abweichung der Verbrauchsanzeige in der MFA noch abhängen ? (spez. VP TDI)
greetings, peter
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:21.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
R.M. Schrauber

Joined: 06/15/2004 Posts: 389 Karma: +14 / -0 Location: DD
Support
|
07-10-2008, 13:29 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
Hardware modifications, such as different nozzles (including worn ones?) or feed pistons.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:23.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
neubaupe Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
07-10-2008, 13:30 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
also auch verschlissener hochdruckkolben ?
In which areas (+/- l/km) does the leakage occur with closed nozzles or worn pistons?
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:23.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
R.M. Schrauber

Joined: 06/15/2004 Posts: 389 Karma: +14 / -0 Location: DD
Support
|
07-10-2008, 13:36 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
Sure. The software doesn't have any error correction for worn-out hardware.
(speculation on)
The deviation should be in the same direction as with the nozzles, meaning the actual consumption should be higher than the displayed value.
(speculation off)
The amount likely depends on the degree of wear. This should be a gradual process. Therefore, I can't give you an exact number. When upgrading from .205 to .216 injectors, the difference was 1.5 to 2.0 liters. I would expect the increased fuel consumption due to wear to be less than that.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:24.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
neubaupe Guest
Free account, no CAN development support
|
07-10-2008, 13:42 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
I think it's the opposite.
The actual consumption will be lower than the consumption indicated by the MFA (Manufacturer's Fuel Consumption).
However, I am not entirely sure, but I assume that the amount of fuel injected is determined by measuring the position of the control slide above the metering hole of the high-pressure piston.
So, a worn piston, even with the same movement, would result in a lower volumetric efficiency (STG), which would mean less fuel being delivered (=loss of power?).
Best regards.
peter
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:26.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Klausel Blaumann

Joined: 05/09/2002 Posts: 223 Karma: +4 / -0
Premium Support
|
07-10-2008, 13:53 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
I can't comment on worn pistons, but I can talk about replacing the injectors.
Before replacing the injectors (160,000 km), I had a fuel consumption of +0.2 liters.
After replacing the nozzles (with standard nozzles again), I had...
-0.1 liters of consumption - so MFA initially showed too little, and then too much.
It involves a lot.
Best regards, Klaus.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:27.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
R.M. Schrauber

Joined: 06/15/2004 Posts: 389 Karma: +14 / -0 Location: DD
Support
|
07-10-2008, 13:54 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
Here again, I see the comparison to worn nozzles. You automatically give it more gas to achieve the "usual" performance. The system's efficiency also decreases due to wear -> increased fuel consumption.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:27.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
Klausel Blaumann

Joined: 05/09/2002 Posts: 223 Karma: +4 / -0
Premium Support
|
07-10-2008, 14:04 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
R.M. wrote: | | Again, I see a comparison to worn nozzles. You automatically give it more gas to achieve the "usual" performance. The system's efficiency also decreases due to wear -> increased fuel consumption. |
It doesn't seem plausible to me; we're talking about the deviation.
Display showing actual consumption, not just the amount.
I think the difference lies in the change of geometry.
to check the nozzle holes for signs of wear, possibly.
Does more fuel pass through under the same pressure and time?
new.
Best regards, Klaus.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:28.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
R.M. Schrauber

Joined: 06/15/2004 Posts: 389 Karma: +14 / -0 Location: DD
Support
|
07-10-2008, 14:16 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
When the injectors wear out and their geometry changes, they no longer atomize the diesel fuel as effectively, which reduces efficiency and results in a loss of power. However, the engine control unit (ECU) is unaware of this, and continues to calculate fuel consumption based on the assumption of intact injectors and using the old correction factors for an optimal system, thus displaying an inaccurate fuel consumption reading. A similar principle should apply to the pistons.
The accelerator pedal then ensures a sufficient supply of fuel to the injectors, allowing you to maintain the same speed and flow with traffic as before. At least, that's my experience.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:30.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
Klausel Blaumann

Joined: 05/09/2002 Posts: 223 Karma: +4 / -0
Premium Support
|
07-10-2008, 14:31 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
R.M. wrote: | | When the nozzles wear out and the geometry changes, they no longer atomize the diesel as well, which reduces efficiency and results in a loss of power. |
It doesn't have any impact on the MFA deviation.
If the fuel injection quantity is, for example, 40 mg per injection.
If you decide to do that, then that (besides speed) is the only relevant factor.
Größe für die Ermittlung des Verbrauchs/Zeit. WeSure, here is the translation of the text from German to English:
"Which performance?"
bei diesen 40 mg rauskommt, ist doch irrelevant. Crucial.
The accuracy of the display is due to the fact that there are actually 40 mg.
to be injected.
The consequences of poor performance in the gas pedal area are related to...
Accuracy of the display is also irrelevant.
Best regards, Klaus.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:31.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
Albrecht Profi-Schrauber

Joined: 05/11/2002 Posts: 284 Karma: +10 / -0 Location: DD
Support
|
07-10-2008, 17:58 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
Hello everyone,
You're both right.
The MFA (Multifunction Display) is more likely to show inaccurate readings with worn-out hardware, as the amount of fuel entering the cylinder may not be what the engine control unit expects.
The actual consumption will certainly also increase, as the gas flow is adjusted.
Best regards,
01/01-08/08 Passat Variant 35i, 08/96, AFN, 94-283Tkm (5.Gg. defekt)
08/08-07/15 A6 (C5) Av. quattro 6-Gg., EZ 10/02, AKE 189-265Tkm (Kolbenriss)
07/15-09/17 A6 (C6) Av. qu. 6-Gg. 3.0 TDI, CDYC, EZ 05/11 180-210Tkm (verkauft)
08/17-11/17 A6 (C7) Av. qu 3.0 TDI comp.(leasing)
seit 2018 Skoda Roomster 1.6 TDI 5-Gg.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:33.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
Klausel Blaumann

Joined: 05/09/2002 Posts: 223 Karma: +4 / -0
Premium Support
|
07-10-2008, 23:16 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
Albrecht wrote: | Hello everyone,
You're both right.
The MFA (Multifunction Display) is more likely to show inaccurate readings with worn-out hardware, as the amount of fuel entering the cylinder may not be what the engine control unit expects.
Best regards |
That doesn't agree with me, but contradicts me, because...
I described the opposite experience...
Best regards, Klaus.
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:34.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
Uli S. Schrauber

Joined: 07/02/2003 Posts: 338 Karma: +7 / -0 Location: Äußerster Südwesten
Support
|
08-10-2008, 12:19 Subject: MFA Consumption Data: VP TDI Deviation |
Quote |
|
Hello everyone,
R.M. wrote: | Certainly. The software doesn't have any error correction for worn-out hardware.
(speculation on)
The deviation should be in the same direction as with the nozzles, meaning the actual consumption should be higher than the displayed value.
(speculation off)
|
I claim the following:
- Worn nozzles allow more material to pass through than new nozzles, given the same amount specified by the MSG (Material Safety Group), because they typically have a lower opening pressure, which results in slightly earlier opening and slightly later closing -> more material dispensed. It's also possible that the spray holes have become slightly larger due to abrasion, which also allows more material to pass through than expected. Therefore, the consumption is displayed as being lower than it actually is. This aligns with the experiences reported.
- A worn "injector-cylinder" pairing will have the opposite effect because the increased gap will result in more leakage (more fuel will be pushed past the piston into the low-pressure area), causing a smaller amount of fuel to be injected than intended -> resulting in a higher reading than the actual amount.
- Over time, the "rotor of the wing cell pump - roller ring" pairing wears out, causing the roller ring to move backward. This shifts the position of the metering piston, causing it to start its operation slightly further back, and the injection port is opened later than normal. This results in a larger amount of fuel being injected than intended, leading to the display showing a lower-than-actual value.
- die Rollen/Achsen und die Aufnahmen im Rollenring verschleißen sicher auch, wodurch die Hubscheibe inkl Kolben ebenfalls nach hinten wandert. Effect as before.
I also don't know what the net result is. The effects of the wear on the various parts of the pump likely compensate for each other to some extent, although I estimate that the wear on the plunger is significantly less than the wear on the FZP disc or the roller ring. Therefore, a worn-out pump is likely to indicate a lower value overall. A car with a worn-out injection system is likely to generally show a lower fuel consumption ("Wow, my TDI with 400,000 km only uses 4 l/100km"  ).
These are my ideas about it (some of them are borrowed  ), I can't say anything about the quantitative aspects, but my AFN doesn't have a consumption display  .
Best regards, Uli.
Golf2 GTD AAZ, LLK, CYP
Bus T3 JX
Passat 32B SB, LLK, Garett T2, 2N
2x Golf2 GTD/SB
alle fahren/fuhren ganzjährig frauentauglich mit 100% Pflanzenöl
97er Golf 3 AFN, 70-100% Pöl
97er Golf 3 Variant AFN
96er Passat 35i AFN
Translated on 26-10-2026, 16:37.
|
|
| Back to top |
Profile PM |
 |
|