VCDS and OBD diagnostic device in the On-Board Diagnostics Shop
Wrenchers and tuners: diesel, petrol, OBD/VCDS. Repair, maintenance, diagnostics - help that's proven on the car.

23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss

 
Go to page: 1, 2  Next
New Topic Reply 🔗 ⭐ 🖨 Dieselschrauber - Index » On-Board Diagnostics (OBD)
Author Message
Mc_Givertechnik
Schrauber
Schrauber


Joined: 02/27/2003
Posts: 390
Karma: +3 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Graz Österreich
2010 Volkswagen T5
Premium Support

Post25-04-2012, 13:33    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Hello and greetings to you all!

Since autumn 2011, I have been dealing with the issue that the MSG update (action 23H8) performed on the 2.0 CR engines in many T5 GPs, including my Multivan Startline CAAC, has resulted in increased fuel consumption of approximately 1 to 1.5 liters and a loss of power in the higher RPM range.

"I observed the whole thing for a while; the temperatures had already dropped far below 0°C, and the car was equipped with winter tires. Through surveys on the T5 forum, I then realized that I wasn't alone in my observations."

Before the update, my T5 GP, which now only has 16,000 km on the odometer, would quickly accelerate to 170 km/h, and then, after a short wait, the speedometer would show 200 km/h. This was without the engine seeming strained. Now, it simply stops at 170 km/h; it doesn't go any faster. From 120 km/h onwards, the engine seems strained. The average fuel consumption was 9 liters per 100 km. In city driving, the average consumption was between 10 and 11 liters, depending on the distance. On the highway, at speeds between 140 and 150 km/h, the fuel consumption was 10 liters.
Currently, we're getting 13 to 14 liters per 100 kilometers in city driving, and at least 11 liters per 100 kilometers on the highway. On country roads, if you drive smoothly, you can achieve real-world fuel consumption figures that are in line with today's technology.

In my case, I always use the same highway route with the same load for comparison. The city driving is within acceptable limits. However, I can no longer achieve a range of 800 km with a full tank; the tank capacity is just under 80 liters.

After inquiring with my VW dealer, I received two different answers:
1.) The official response: We are not aware of this, and we will send an inquiry to VW, but we don't expect much.
2.) The unofficial solution: We're familiar with this, but he can't do anything about it because VW isn't offering any assistance. Many customers are complaining about this problem, not just with the T5.

I then saw the reply that was sent to the dealer. The response from VW stated: "This issue is not known to us. A comparative test should be carried out with a similar vehicle."

I haven't laughed this much in a long time. Besides the fact that all the T5 models available at dealerships have the same update installed, it's rare to find a dealership with a comparable vehicle simply sitting there.

I have now contacted Volkswagen directly in writing. Of course, they immediately informed my dealer, who now wants to arrange a test drive with me:

50 km of highway.
50 km of federal highway.
20 km city.

Everything is logged and then sent to Volkswagen.
I also need to collect and create records for fuel expenses.
Is it all on me?

Is this procedure known?

You'll never be able to achieve the fuel consumption figures listed in the brochure with this car.

Or is this a tactic of attrition, essentially keeping the customer engaged for so long that they eventually give up...?

Greetings,

Peter.
VW T5 GP Multivan Startline CAAC 2,0 CRD 103 KW, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2001, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2003;Renault Zoe PHII 135 2020;


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:13.
Back to top Profile PM Email Garage
Autoservice
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber
Avatar-Autoservice

Joined: 04/14/2012
Posts: 2130
Karma: +99 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Nähe Düsseldorf

Support

Post25-04-2012, 13:57    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Quote:
Or is this a tactic of attrition, in a way, where I keep the customer occupied for so long that they give up...?


This is a first attempt. What will result from this?

Without the possibility of a test drive through the icon_lol.gif, probably nothing can happen from Volkswagen's point of view.
LG, Onkel BM

*Nichts ist einfacher, als sich schwierig auszudrücken......*

**Technische Fragen bitte ins Forum und nicht in mein Postfach**


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:17.
Back to top Profile PM
Mc_Givertechnik
Schrauber
Schrauber


Joined: 02/27/2003
Posts: 390
Karma: +3 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Graz Österreich
2010 Volkswagen T5
Premium Support

Post10-07-2012, 5:48    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Hello!

A lot of time has passed since then, and the following has happened:

After a long waiting period and a personal complaint to VW, a test drive was finally conducted. The setup was that I drove the car, while the workshop manager sat in the passenger seat and monitored the data. The workshop manager himself was not allowed to drive the test drive because, in Austria, the speed limit on highways is 130 km/h, and he is not permitted to exceed that limit.

"The maximum speed at full throttle on a flat highway with no wind is 170 km/h, possibly even a little more. During testing, it was around 160 to 165 km/h, which is definitely not the speed that was previously achievable."

The logged data was then sent to VW Salzburg, the Austrian VW headquarters. After several inquiries and many phone calls regarding this matter, I was informed that another test drive would be conducted using a vehicle that is nearly identical.

For a long time, I was told with regret by the service manager at my VW dealership that no vehicle was available for a test drive. Weeks went by. However, yesterday, while I was on the phone with the workshop manager about a different issue, I was suddenly informed that two vehicles were available, and that test drives had been conducted with each of them. Both T5s reached a maximum speed of 175 to 180 km/h according to the speedometer.

I explained to the workshop manager that while this amount would still be low, it would confirm the deficiency in my T5, as it would not reach the specified build speed.

Here it comes.

According to the workshop manager, everything is fine, because my T5 also reaches its maximum speed as indicated by the speedometer.

Taking into account the MFA display, which already shows a less divergent value, my T5 doesn't even reach 170 km/h. If you consider the value from the tester at the dealership, it's even lower.

What's the situation now? In my opinion, we are using the most accurate measuring tools available, in this case, the testers. Therefore, the most accurate possible value should always be considered.

Unfortunately, I haven't had the opportunity to record the speed using GPS yet.

How would you proceed from here? Has any new information become available regarding this issue?

What does the case law say about recording the mileage of a vehicle?

Greetings,

Peter.
VW T5 GP Multivan Startline CAAC 2,0 CRD 103 KW, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2001, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2003;Renault Zoe PHII 135 2020;


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:20.
Back to top Profile PM Email Garage
pax
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber
Avatar-pax

Joined: 12/10/2003
Posts: 426
Karma: +10 / -0   Thank you, like it!

2000 Volkswagen Passat
Support

Post10-07-2012, 6:52    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Hello,

I once inquired at a university, and they had a test setup where the NEFZ (New European Driving Cycle) test could be performed. I recall it costing around 1000 euros, and it would certainly be an accepted proof of fuel consumption anomalies by Volkswagen.

Qualifying the reference measurement device in speed tests can be a bit tricky when an accurate absolute value is required. Who says that speed is measured more accurately via GPS than by the speedometer? Generally, this is an inherently inaccurate method, where the actual measured values are typically filtered to improve the result. Some sources of error are also not easy to determine (e.g., the number of satellites at the time of measurement, the strength of signal interference, etc.). I can't estimate this in absolute numbers, but I believe this method is not particularly suitable for determining speed at a specific point in time with high accuracy.

It might be feasible to record a characteristic curve for the speedometer reading on a rolling test stand with a known error in the speed measurement, essentially creating a relationship between the actual speed (v_World) and the speedometer reading (v_Tacho). This would certainly be an acceptable vehicle-to-world calibration, provided that the tire pressure and contact area are reasonably consistent.

Bye.
peace


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:24.
Back to top Profile PM Garage
Mc_Givertechnik
Schrauber
Schrauber


Joined: 02/27/2003
Posts: 390
Karma: +3 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Graz Österreich
2010 Volkswagen T5
Premium Support

Post10-07-2012, 7:38    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Hello!

So, in short, it will probably be a report from an expert.

The whole situation isn't developing the way I would like it to, or the way I had hoped.

It seems VW is once again trying to evade responsibility. The comparative tests they conducted are apparently intended to disprove exactly what I have been criticizing.

After posting a question on the T5 forum, "How fast do your T5 GP 140 PS TDI models run?", I mostly received answers indicating speeds exceeding 175 km/h.

The problem is that the brochure promises a speed of "173 km/h in fifth gear." That's probably achievable. And it seems my bus also meets this specification, which would invalidate my complaint.

My bus, when purchased, could reach speeds of 190 to 200 km/h, but the software update reduced its performance. This eliminated the positive variation in performance that was present in the original production models.

Furthermore, the problem of excessive consumption remains unresolved.

Greetings,

Peter.
VW T5 GP Multivan Startline CAAC 2,0 CRD 103 KW, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2001, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2003;Renault Zoe PHII 135 2020;


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:27.
Back to top Profile PM Email Garage
alevuz
Schrauber
Schrauber


Joined: 11/27/2011
Posts: 113
Karma: +32 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Tirol

Premium Support

Post11-07-2012, 18:03    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Hello,

I hope you're not expecting too much from this.

I think it's quite borderline that a T5 with 140 hp can reach 200 km/h. My Golf also doesn't easily reach 200 km/h, and it has a little more than 140 hp.
When driving a "big" car with over 300 horsepower, you'll start to feel the effects of wind resistance quite noticeably at speeds above 190 km/h. In terms of aerodynamics, the T5 and Treg I models likely won't differ significantly. Plus, we here in Tyrol can easily drive to our neighbors in Bavaria to legally test this.

I believe it's important to be realistic. The T5, with its current engine configuration, simply lacks the necessary displacement. This "little engine" in such a relatively heavy and bulky vehicle won't perform miracles and won't be able to set new fuel efficiency records.

(My opinion!!)

If it helps:

With the 170 hp PPD TDI engines (around 2008), even an update caused the same problems: there was a loss of power, fuel consumption increased, and this drove some owners crazy because these vehicles could only reach around 200 km/h instead of the advertised ~225 km/h.

SG.
Alevuz.
Golf V 2.0 TDI - 4motion (BKD) im Ruhezustand mit >500Tkm
Golf 7 Alltrack - 4motion (DGCA)
Passat Alltrack - 4motion (CFGC)
Touareg V10 TDI (AYH)


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:30.
Back to top Profile PM
chriskross
Blaumann
Blaumann


Joined: 04/19/2006
Posts: 304
Karma: +3 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Österreich

Premium Support

Post11-07-2012, 19:08    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Hello!


I would like to have the original software installed. It's not really a problem.

"This should be something that any tuner should be able to do."
A6 AFB

A6 BRE DPF


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:32.
Back to top Profile PM
mullemaus
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post11-07-2012, 19:10    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Hello!


I would like to have the original software installed, which shouldn't be a problem.

Every tuner should be able to do that.

But only with the option to open the control unit. And now, let's think further about the issue of the warranty. icon_lol.gif icon_wink.gif


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:32.
Back to top
Mc_Givertechnik
Schrauber
Schrauber


Joined: 02/27/2003
Posts: 390
Karma: +3 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Graz Österreich
2010 Volkswagen T5
Premium Support

Post11-07-2012, 19:39    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

And that's exactly what I want to "avoid" for now, as long as I haven't gone through everything with VW. Next on the agenda is the legal route. I still have some time.

Greetings,

Peter.
VW T5 GP Multivan Startline CAAC 2,0 CRD 103 KW, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2001, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2003;Renault Zoe PHII 135 2020;


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:33.
Back to top Profile PM Email Garage
chris11
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 10/02/2002
Posts: 326
Karma: +3 / -1   Thank you, like it!
Location: Münster

Premium Support

Post11-07-2012, 20:59    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

The engine probably had around 180 horsepower originally. I don't think you have any right to expect that. VW likely reduced the power output and average combustion temperature so that the engine would at least last for the warranty period for VW.

Best regards.
Christian.


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:34.
Back to top Profile PM
mullemaus
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post11-07-2012, 21:05    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

The engine probably had around 180 horsepower before. You don't have a right to demand that, IMHO.

Yes. He may only deviate within the 'tolerance' range. It was probably something like 10...15% up or down, according to various rulings. (Serial spread) If he exceeds that, the manufacturer MUST make corrections icon_wink.gif.


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:34.
Back to top
chris11
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 10/02/2002
Posts: 326
Karma: +3 / -1   Thank you, like it!
Location: Münster

Premium Support

Post11-07-2012, 22:06    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Actually, VW did. They increased the horsepower to 140, which is what's stated in the vehicle registration document.

Best regards.
Christian.


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:35.
Back to top Profile PM
mullemaus
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post11-07-2012, 22:12    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Actually, VW did. He modified it to have 140 horsepower, which is what's stated in the vehicle registration document.

Who says it, and where does it stand? icon_eek.gif


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:36.
Back to top
chris11
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 10/02/2002
Posts: 326
Karma: +3 / -1   Thank you, like it!
Location: Münster

Premium Support

Post11-07-2012, 22:16    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

Quote:
Multivan Startline CAAC


In the first post.

Best regards.
Christian.


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:36.
Back to top Profile PM
mullemaus
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post11-07-2012, 22:23    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

It doesn't state that it was transferred from xxxPS/NM to XXXPS/NM.

Therefore, no one can say they have 140 horsepower NOW. Unless I can't read the post correctly icon_lol.gif icon_lol.gif icon_wink.gif.


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:37.
Back to top
chris11
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 10/02/2002
Posts: 326
Karma: +3 / -1   Thank you, like it!
Location: Münster

Premium Support

Post11-07-2012, 22:37    Subject: 23H8 STG Update VW T5 GP: Fuel Consumption & Power Loss Quote

The T5 has a large cross-section and doesn't have a record-breaking drag coefficient (Cw). At high speeds, the top speed is essentially dependent on air resistance. Therefore, the top speed is proportional to the cube root of the engine power. If you consider the engine power options that correlate with the speeds mentioned above, and assuming a speedometer error of approximately 10 km/h at 200 km/h, you end up with roughly 180 horsepower.

Best regards.
Christian.


Translated on 15-10-2026, 18:37.
Back to top Profile PM
New Topic Reply 🔗 ⭐ 🖨 Dieselschrauber - Index » On-Board Diagnostics (OBD)
Go to page: 1, 2  Next
Similar articles and topics
Topic Forum
No new posts VCDS: HEX-USB CAN adapter not found after update General Tips
No new posts VAG-COM Log: VW T4 High Fuel Consumption Issues Upload
No new posts Biodiesel Consumption: ESP/ESD Leakage Issues Diesel Engine Technology
No new posts ASZ Logs: Vibration & Excessive Consumption Upload
No new posts Passat 3B: V6 TDI AFB - Power Loss & Fuel Consumption Diesel Engine Technology
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum.