VCDS and OBD diagnostic device in the On-Board Diagnostics Shop
Diesel, Engine Technology and Vehicle Technology. Repair, Maintenance and Diagnostics (OBD).

Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You?

 
Go to page: 1, 2  Next
New Topic Reply 🔗 🖨 Dieselschrauber - Index » Diesel Engine Technology
Author Message
WarLord
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post28-10-2003, 23:54    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

'Since my engine oil needs to be changed again, I'm currently wondering which engine oil is good. I've been using 10W40 so far, and now I want to switch to 5W40 (0W40 seems to wash out all the dirt, and then the engine consumes the oil like crazy). Am I correct in assuming that 5W40 won't wash out the engine, or should I stick with the thinner oil? Which 10W40 is a good one? The engine has 168,000 km on it, and the oil change is overdue by 1,000 km. As for the oil filter, it doesn't really matter which one I choose, right?'

Best regards, WarLord.


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:28.
Back to top
olli
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 05/24/2002
Posts: 581
Karma: +46 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Berlin

Premium Support

Post29-10-2003, 0:01    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

Hi,
I highly doubt that you're doing anything wrong by using 5W40. I've been driving my car for four years and 160,000 km, and I've used either 10W40 or 5W40 (whatever synthetic oil my trusted mechanic had available at the time), and I haven't experienced any increased oil consumption (no need to top it up during an oil change interval) or any leaks from any seals or shaft seals (knocking on wood...).

Olli.

A6 C4 AEL /96 239,000 km


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:29.
Back to top Profile PM
matthiasTDI96
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 02/27/2003
Posts: 5886
Karma: +251 / -0   Thank you, like it!


Premium Support

Post29-10-2003, 8:27    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

"I agree with that. As long as it meets the VW standard, I would opt for a relatively thin oil (5W), since winter is just around the corner. Be glad that you have the choice... In my last oil change (PD Longlife), it was really difficult to find products that met the standard at reasonable prices in our town."

By the way, I'm also experiencing the same issue. What PD Longlife oil do you recommend? Currently, I'm using Castrol SLX.


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:30.
Back to top Profile PM
joergs
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post29-10-2003, 8:50    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

'To be honest, the brand doesn't really matter to me, as long as it meets the appropriate VW standard! (I think yours is 505 00). For my 1Z, I always bought a 5W40 full synthetic oil from the hardware store for about 17-20 euros for a 5-liter container. It got me about 140,000 km with the car. And the car still runs like a dream, and I'm still using the same oil. Today, it has 235,000 km on the clock!'

@matthiasTDI96
'I can't really comment on long-life oil, as I only use fixed-interval oil in my AWX (so not the 506 xx, but the 505 01). I have the same problem as you! It's always quite difficult to find something at a reasonable price! I once found a supplier in Westfalen. If I remember correctly, I paid around 25 euros for 5 liters of 5w40 oil that meets the VW standard 505 01. This oil was also listed in MichaelII's oil compatibility table! I think you can probably find that oil at a good price on the big online auction site! I'll also have to start looking again, as I'll need to change the oil again in the next 4000 km.'


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:32.
Back to top
wollif
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post29-10-2003, 8:59    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which One Is Right? Quote

The oil filter, it doesn't really matter which one I choose, does it?


Morning.

I wouldn't necessarily go for the cheapest option. I trust the quality of the internal components of Bosch or Mahle filters the most.

Regards,
wollif

1 Owner, year 1994, 250,000 km.


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:34.
Back to top
Julian
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post29-10-2003, 9:15    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote


By the way: I also have one installed in my car. What PD Longlife oil do you recommend? Currently, I'm using Castrol SLX.

Da machst Du nichts falsch. Die Marke ist eh unwichtig und durch 50601 bist Du gebunden an das 0W-30. Achte halt nur immer auf 50601, mir wurde schon mehrfach in der Werkstatt das 50600 in die Hand gedrückt (zum Nachfüllen), im Lager haben die da nciht so drauf geachtet. Ich überlege nun, das Öl zur Inspektion mitzunehmen, damit auch das richtige eingefüllt wird. Man I never know.

by the way
Do you have the AWX in the A4?


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:35.
Back to top
Thomas K
Blaumann
Blaumann


Joined: 10/07/2002
Posts: 117
Karma: +3 / -0   Thank you, like it!


Premium Support

Post29-10-2003, 9:19    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

"During the last oil change, I used 0W... oil, which meets the VW standard. It was only about 6€ more expensive than the 10W oil. I've driven about 6000km since then, but there's been no measurable oil consumption (I could check again). What's more noticeable is the lower diesel consumption, averaging 0.2 - 0.3 L/100km less."
"I used to switch to a full synthetic 0W60 Delo oil at around 100,000 km on my Kadett, and I also noticed a slight decrease in fuel consumption. I didn't experience any problems with increased oil consumption."
Gruß Thomas

VW EOS 2,0 TSI; BWA; Bj. 06/2006
September 2020 ca. 180.000km

VW Bora Variant, AJM, Bj. 04/2001
04/2016 verkauft mit 378.000km


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:36.
Back to top Profile PM
Wurstblinker
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post29-10-2003, 9:26    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

Hi,
Here, a liter of LongLife oil costs €11, but it's okay if you buy 5 liters.

http://www.motoroel-direkt.de/high_performer.html



Sure, here is the translation of the text from German to English:

'MFG' is an abbreviation for 'Mit freundlichen Grüßen,' which means 'Sincerely' or 'Best regards' in English.


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:37.
Back to top
haehnlein
Schrauber
Schrauber


Joined: 08/22/2002
Posts: 877
Karma: +6 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Griesheim

Support

Post29-10-2003, 15:41    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

Hi,

I'm just saying, 280,000 km with Audi bo 1z and LiquiMoly 15W40 HD for €20 (5 liters, meets VW standard). The car is still running great. My old Passat made it to 330,000 km with it. It's better to change it more often and replace the filter every time icon_wink.gif.
____________

Für Antworten danke ich Euch im Voraus. Gruß Christian

Kein Auto mehr!


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:38.
Back to top Profile PM
Roger
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber
Avatar-Roger

Joined: 10/11/2002
Posts: 3035
Karma: +88 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Rodgau
2017 Volkswagen Golf
Premium Support

Post29-10-2003, 17:02    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

@Wurstblinker:

If you're okay with the minimum order quantity of 12 units, you can get the 50601 for €8.90 here:
http://www.motoroel-direkt.de/BP_Visco_7000_Longlife_II_0W-30.html

We currently have two cars with WIV, a 4.5-liter engine, and a 3-liter engine. I can easily get the rest from my colleagues with open arms icon_wink.gif.

It is essential to use the correct specification. The viscosity alone does not provide enough information. However, in the past, there have been problems with the additives used in highly viscous oils, such as 10W-60. In some cases, the additives did not burn completely. For this reason, such oils are not approved by VW for use in more demanding engines.
Gruß
Roger

MJ 2018 GTI Performance DLBA

//images.spritmonitor.de/880099.png


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:39.
Back to top Profile PM Garage
pepe
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post30-10-2003, 23:03    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

Why does Volkswagen Racing use 10W60 oil in their TDI engines?

I think these are definitely among the more sophisticated engines!


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:40.
Back to top
Mc_Givertechnik
Schrauber
Schrauber


Joined: 02/27/2003
Posts: 390
Karma: +3 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Graz Österreich
2010 Volkswagen T5
Premium Support

Post30-10-2003, 23:11    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

Hello everyone!

"Since I also use long-life oil in my 2.5 ACV engine, I'm constantly interested in oil prices. The quality of the oils isn't really that different. If it meets the specified standard, it's generally usable. However, I only use branded oils, although that doesn't necessarily mean much, since for example, Castrol doesn't produce a single drop of oil itself, but rather has it produced or purchases it. Due to good relationships, I use a 0W-40, fully synthetic oil from OMV. I pay around €8.30 per liter."

I've had some interesting experiences with filters. Out of curiosity, I've even cut open some filters to see the difference. For example, one filter from the company UFI was a coffee filter in a metal can, completely unnecessary, a waste of money and harmful to the engine. I trust filters from the companies Bosch, Fiam, Mahle, and Mann. I don't use anything else.

Regards, Peter.
VW T5 GP Multivan Startline CAAC 2,0 CRD 103 KW, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2001, Audi A2 1,4 16V AUA 2003;Renault Zoe PHII 135 2020;


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:42.
Back to top Profile PM Email Garage
WarLord
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post30-10-2003, 23:39    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

Okay, one more silly question: Which filter fits in my TDI? As you probably know by now, the engine is a 1Z in a 1996 Passat 35i B4 3A5.

Best regards, WarLord.


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:43.
Back to top
wollif
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post31-10-2003, 9:04    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

Which filter? Just look at the list that's next to it at the store.
It's more problematic to remove the filter without it looking like there's just been a shift change on an oil rig... At least, that's the case with the 1Z engine in the Golf III.


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:44.
Back to top
Thomas
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/17/2002
Posts: 329
Karma: +2 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Darmstadt

Support

Post01-11-2003, 20:22    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote

Hi,

Quote:
It's more problematic to remove the filter without it looking like a shift change just happened on an oil drilling platform... At least with the 1Z engine in the Golf III.


icon_biggrin.gif It's the same with the AFN Golf 3. At least without a lift or a pit, I find it quite nice every time! Unfortunately, mine has air conditioning, which doesn't exactly make things easier. *g*

Greetings.
Thomas.
-----------------------------------------------------
Golf 3 TDI AFN Bj. 1997 -verkauft
Audi S2 ADU Bj. 1993
Polo 86c 2F 1W Bj. 1994 - verkauft
Audi A3 TDI ASZ Bj. 2001


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:44.
Back to top Profile PM
WarLord
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post02-11-2003, 19:03    Subject: Best Motor Oil: Which Oil Is Right for You? Quote


It's more problematic to remove the filter without it looking like there's just been a shift change on an oil drilling platform... At least with the 1Z in the Golf III.

Well, it doesn't really bother me. You get used to getting dirty when you're working on a car.

Best regards, WarLord.


Translated on 13-09-2026, 5:45.
Back to top
New Topic Reply 🔗 🖨 Dieselschrauber - Index » Diesel Engine Technology
Go to page: 1, 2  Next
Similar articles and topics
Topic Forum
This topic is locked, you cannot edit or reply. Which oil? Diesel Engine Technology
No new posts Which Oil? Best Oil Types & Uses. Diesel Engine Technology
No new posts AJM Engine Oil: Which One is Best? Diesel Engine Technology
No new posts Which engine oil for WIV? Diesel Engine Technology
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum.