VCDS and OBD diagnostic device in the On-Board Diagnostics Shop
Diesel technology, engine technology, vehicle diagnostics, repair & maintenance.

Wheel offset problem: ET 45 versus ET 33

 
New Topic Reply 🔗 🖨 Dieselschrauber - Index » Transmission, Chassis, Body & Interior
Author Message
Burki
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post04-10-2005, 18:43    Subject: Wheel offset problem: ET 45 versus ET 33 Quote

Hi, I was offered a set of winter tires on steel rims from an Audi A4 today for my A6 (C4). The tire size is correct (195/65 R15), and the rim is identical to mine except for the offset (6J x 15 H2). However, my offset is 45mm, while the offered rims have an offset of 33mm. This would result in a 'wheel offset increase' of 12mm. It has enough space in the wheel well; I used to have 20mm wheel spacers on my car myself.
Does anyone know if the rims from an A6 can fit on another car? Perhaps other drivers have faced the same question before.
Best regards & thank you for the tips.
Burki.
Back to top
ulf
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/13/2002
Posts: 11058
Karma: +18 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Saarland
2023 MG ZS
Premium Support

Post04-10-2005, 19:07    Subject: Re: Rim problem: Offset 45 vs. Offset 33 Quote

Burki wrote:
Does anyone know if you can use the rims from an A6 on another car?

Does the vehicle registration document not specify the wheel size, including...? Is ET included?

If yes and "33 mm" is not included, you are not allowed to drive (or register) it.
Gruß Ulf
_________

MG4 Electric
Back to top Profile PM Garage
lappen
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post04-10-2005, 19:34    Subject: Wheel offset problem: ET 45 versus ET 33 Quote

However, there are exceptions, such as for winter tires. It's best to ask a reputable tire service and/or a VAG workshop. With the 3B Passat, a different part number could be installed along with winter tires, even if it wasn't listed in the vehicle registration document. Unfortunately, I don't remember the exact dates at the moment.
Back to top
Burki
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post04-10-2005, 20:21    Subject: The vehicle registration document states... Quote

The vehicle registration document only states: '... depending on the equipment, rim size A: 6JX15H2 or 7JX15H2...' and lists a few other rim sizes, but all the information is given without specifying the offset! I asked VAG, but they were only interested in selling their winter tire sets.
Best regards, Burki.
Back to top
ulf
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/13/2002
Posts: 11058
Karma: +18 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: Saarland
2023 MG ZS
Premium Support

Post04-10-2005, 20:55    Subject: Re: The vehicle registration document states... Quote

Burki wrote:
all specifications without pressing depth!

Wow, did you know that still exists?

Then I would definitely install the ET 33 offset if it fits properly on the hub and looks like it has enough clearance.
Because the effort involved in checking with the manufacturer about something that appears "unobjectionable" at first glance, and without any obvious violation of the information on the certificate, is something that "almost certainly" no one will bother to do.
Gruß Ulf
_________

MG4 Electric
Back to top Profile PM Garage
Burki
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post05-10-2005, 8:42    Subject: I guess I'll do it that way Quote

I guess I'll do it that way (if everything else works out). Thanks for the tips.
Best regards, Burki.
Back to top
Martin L.
Guest




 


Free account, no CAN development support

Post06-10-2005, 16:53    Subject: Wheel offset problem: ET 45 versus ET 33 Quote

In my case, the offset is 45mm, while the offered rims have an offset of 33mm. That would be a 'track widening' of 12 mm.
Okay, I'm being picky, but the track width extension is 24 mm icon_biggrin.gif.
Back to top
fulda



Joined: 09/28/2005
Posts: 129
Karma: +4 / -3   Thank you, like it!


Free account, no CAN development support

Post02-01-2006, 11:35    Subject: Wheel offset problem: ET 45 versus ET 33 Quote

Hello!

For me, this whole thing is called "ET 38 versus ET 35!" However, legally speaking, the different offset depth does not automatically invalidate the operating permit, but rather the tires must also be a causal factor in an accident, or what? icon_eek.gif
Back to top Profile PM
Bertil
Profi-Schrauber
Profi-Schrauber


Joined: 04/15/2002
Posts: 5628
Karma: +108 / -0   Thank you, like it!


Premium Support

Post02-01-2006, 13:44    Subject: Wheel offset problem: ET 45 versus ET 33 Quote

fulda wrote:
...
Legally speaking, however, it is the case that the different indentation depth does not automatically invalidate the operating permit, but rather that the tires must also be a causal factor in an accident, or?


No!

In Germany, at least, the approval (ABE) for a vehicle is invalidated if it has unauthorized accessories. In the worst-case scenario, the insurance coverage might even be voided.
Whether someone will blame you in the event of an accident depends entirely on who is conducting the investigation. So, simply put, whether he notices it or not.
From a legal standpoint, the matter is clear. The operating license has expired. Without any reservations.
Gruß Bertil

Skoda 5E5 CZDA + Mini R50 W10 + VW ID.3 + Fiat Ducato 250 + 161 DX

*** Technische Anfragen per PN werden von mir nicht beantwortet! ***
Back to top Profile PM
fulda



Joined: 09/28/2005
Posts: 129
Karma: +4 / -3   Thank you, like it!


Free account, no CAN development support

Post04-01-2006, 12:11    Subject: Wheel offset problem: ET 45 versus ET 33 Quote

Bertil wrote:
fulda wrote:
...
Legally speaking, however, it is the case that the different indentation depth does not automatically invalidate the operating permit, but rather that the tires must also be a causal factor in an accident, or?


No!


"It is not permitted to mount a rim that is not approved in the type approval certificate."
and results in the vehicle being deemed unsafe for road use and operation.
is valid - therefore, you risk penalties, and being held partially responsible for a traffic accident.
It is unlikely to be constructed solely for this reason
!

That's what the legal department of Graz-Ost/ÖAMTC-Styria says! icon_mrgreen.gif new_all_coholic.gif
Back to top Profile PM
dieselschrauber
Administrator
Administrator
Avatar-dieselschrauber

Joined: 04/12/2002
Posts: 17993
Karma: +782 / -0   Thank you, like it!
Location: St.Gallen
2018 Volkswagen T6 Consumption


Post04-01-2006, 12:31    Subject: Wheel offset problem: ET 45 versus ET 33 Quote

fulda wrote:


"It is not permitted to mount a rim that is not approved in the type approval certificate."
and results in the vehicle being deemed unsafe for road use and operation.
is valid - therefore, you risk penalties, and being held partially responsible for a traffic accident.
It is unlikely to be constructed solely for this reason
!

"That's what the legal department of Graz-Ost/ÖAMTC-Styria says!" icon_mrgreen.gif new_all_coholic.gif


Hi,

The situation, however, can change very quickly if you drive over a manhole cover in the curve, the wheel that is now further out/in rubs against the wheel arch, and it forces you out of the curve and into the path of an oncoming car icon_exclaim.gif.

The standard test at the TÜV, which involves loading the car with sandbags and checking the free movement of the wheels, is a useful procedure.

Best regards, Rainer.
Dipl.-Ing. (FH) Rainer Kaufmann - dieselschrauber VCDS Shop
Back to top Profile PM WWW Garage
New Topic Reply 🔗 🖨 Dieselschrauber - Index » Transmission, Chassis, Body & Interior
Similar articles and topics
Topic Forum
No new posts Karosserie nach Unfall ----> Felgenproblem Transmission, Chassis, Body & Interior
No new posts Anschraubpunkte 2.0TDI BKD/AZV versus 1.9TDI ASZ/ALH/ARL usw Diesel Engine Technology
No new posts Glühkerzen Unterschied Audi 3,0 TDI 059 963 319E versus J Diesel Engine Technology
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum.