Are you sure that the Schaetz-Eisen gauge is displaying the correct readings for that Golf 2 (Jetta)?
There are two temperature sensors on the water flange. Simply swap the connections, and if it then displays the temperature "correctly," then the sensor is faulty.
If it still shows too much, then either both sensors are broken

or the device is actually getting too hot.
I still can't guess it, sorry.
m;